Best Holster for Sig P238 – Top 7 Best Sig P238 Holsters Reviews

Looking for the best holster for the SIG P238?

Then you’ve come to the right place. In this guide, we’ll go over everything you need to know to choose the right holster for this handy little subcompact.

First, we’ll go over all the different things that you need to consider to make sure you’re choosing not just a good holster, but the right holster for your particular needs. Then we’ll go over a few of our top recommendations for the top holsters for the SIG Sauer P238 currently available. 

Now let’s dive right in.

If you do not have time for the details, here are our top picks for Sig P238 Holster:

1. Badger Concealment Guardian Inside the Waistband Holster
2. Concealment Express OWB Kydex Holster
3. Outbags USA NSC31 Nylon OWB Holster with Mag Pouch
4. DeSantis Nemesis Pocket Holster
5. Alien Gear ShapeShift Shoulder Holster
6. ComfortTac Ultimate Ankle Holster For Concealed Carry
7. Roma Leathers Essential Leather Concealment Crossbody Bag

What to Consider When Choosing a SIG P238 Holster?

It’s important to keep a few things in mind when choosing a holster for your SIG Sauer P238 in order to ensure that you choose a holster that fits your needs.

Carry Position

For one, you need to think about where on your body you want to carry. You also need to think about whether you plan to openly carry or concealed carry.

Fortunately, the subcompact size of the SIG P238 gives you a lot of concealed carry options without having to worry about printing. You can even carry it in a pocket holster. 

If it’s a main firearm, you probably want to keep the gun somewhere that it can be quickly accessed, like along your waistband or in a shoulder holster. A backup gun can be placed on your back or ankle. 

For open carry, you can carry the SIG P238 in about any position you want. 

Ultimately, there’s no wrong position, as long as it works for you. You may even find that your preferred carry position changes depending on your attire and activities for the day, so don’t be afraid to get multiple holsters for added convenience. 

Trigger Coverage

One thing that’s not up to personal preference is trigger coverage. Your holster needs to completely and securely cover the trigger in order to prevent accidental discharges. While your SIG P238 is in the holster, you shouldn’t be able to manipulate the trigger.

For adequate trigger coverage, not only does the trigger need to be completely covered, it needs to be covered with a secure enough material that the trigger can’t be moved through the material.

Many holsters are made from leather or Kydex, which are both firm enough to provide the trigger coverage necessary. Softer materials, like nylon or elastic, may not be sufficient on their own. Fortunately, some holsters made from these materials have kydex shells to cover the trigger. 

Retention

Like trigger coverage, proper retention is essential. You should be able to hold your holster in any orientation and have your gun stay in place.

Holsters ensure adequate retention using either passive retention, adequate retention, or both.

Passive retention systems rely on friction. They squeeze the gun in a hard shell to hold it in place. They typically allow you to adjust the tightness of the shell using screws so you can set the retention just right to hold the gun in place while still able to easily draw your weapon.

Active retention systems using physical barriers like straps or clips to keep the gun in place. Active retention holsters are, generally speaking, less expensive but also slower to draw from than passive retention holsters.

Durability

The easiest way to ensure that you’re choosing a durable holster is by making sure it’s made from a durable material. Fortunately, both of the most common holster materials, Kydex and leather, are highly durable.

Elastic and nylon are less durable than leather and Kydex, but they’re generally durable enough, especially if they’re made from thicker material. They’re also cheaper than leather and Kydex holsters. 

On top of the material, a holster should also be generally well constructed, with secure stitching and hardware. 

Of course, you’ll still need to take good care of your holsters to ensure they last.

Comfort

The comfort of a holster isn’t a safety concern, but it’s still important, particularly for an everyday holster. 

A holster should feel secure and not awkwardly tug on your clothes, making them uncomfortable or forcing you to constantly readjust. If the holster sits close to your skin, it should be breathable. It shouldn’t poke or rub. 

Wearing a layer underneath your holster, such as an undershirt or socks, can help with comfort in many cases, but won’t fix every comfort issue. 

Accessories

Finally, if you have accessories on your firearm, like lights, lasers, or sights, you need to make sure that your holster can accommodate them.

Some holsters are molded to fit the exact shape of the firearm that they’re designed for. In this cases, there may not be room for accessories. However, some have cutouts, open faces, or other features built in to accommodate lights or other accessories. Others are molded to fit the gun with a particular accessory built in, and you’ll need to pick the right one for your gun and accessory combo.

Then there’s also the option of going with a softer holster that’s not designed for a particular firearm. These holsters are usually more forgiving in terms of space and shape, so they may provide enough room for your sights or light. Be sure to check the dimensions listed by the manufacturer against the dimensions of your SIG P238 with your accessories attached.

Best Holster for Sig P238 on the Market Reviews

 1   Badger Concealment Guardian Inside the Waistband Holster

Inside the waistband holsters are the most popular style of holster for concealed carry, so our first recommendation is an IWB holster. 

The Badger Concealment Guardian is an incredibly lightweight and low profile Kydex holster, making it great for concealed carry. It weighs just 3 ounces and Badger Concealment actually advertises it as “the lightest holster on the market. ”

It’s available in a few different versions so you can pick just the right configuration for you. Choose between right and left handed draw, a 1.5 inch or 1.75 inch belt clip, a neutral cant or FBI (15 degree forward) cant, and seven different colors. 

Whichever configuration you go with, you’ll get a hand crafted holster with an injection-molded clip, adjustable retention screws, and a sweat guard to protect your P238 and make holstering easier.

 2   Concealment Express OWB Kydex Holster

Concealed carry can be a bit trickier with an OWB holster, but with a slim, low profile holster like the Concealment Express OWB Kydex Holster, it’s still very doable. 

This is a paddle style holster with a fiber reinforced paddle, so it doesn’t require a belt and it distributes the weight along your waistband and body. This makes the holster more comfortable and prevents it from visibly pulling at and weighing down your clothes. 

The Concealment Express OWB Kydex Holster is designed for hip carry in either the 3 o’clock or 9 o’clock positions and comes in left and right handed versions.

The holster features user adjustable cant from 0 to 15 degrees as well as user adjustable retention. It has an undercut trigger guard for easier draw and an overcoat top, which allows for suppressor height sights. The open face allows for threaded barrels and muzzle accessories. This holster also features a full length sweat guard.

The Concealment Express OWB Kydex Holster is made in the US and comes with a lifetime warranty.

 3   Outbags USA NSC31 Nylon OWB Holster with Mag Pouch

This next holster is a bulkier but cheaper alternative to the Concealment Express OWB holster.

The Outbags USA NSC31 OWB Holster is made out of 600 denier nylon, which keeps it lightweight and durable, while also lowering the price relative to the Concealment Express holster. However, it’s also got a larger profile, which makes it better suited for open carry than concealed carry.

Outbags knows this, so they just leaned into it by adding a mag pouch to the side of the holster, allowing you to carry a spare mag without having to carry an extra mag holster. The pouch will hold magazines up to 5 inches tall and has a velcro strap for retention.

It’s an ambidextrous holster in that you can place the clip on the side you prefer using the included parts, tools, and instructions. The removable steel belt clip can actually be attached to either your waistband or belt. The holster also has a nylon belt loop on both sides. Both the clip and belt can fit belts up to 2 inches wide.

The holster also features an adjustable retention strap with a snap closure, which can be quickly and easily opened with just your thumb. The inside of the holster is lined to protect your P238’s finish.

 4   DeSantis Nemesis Pocket Holster

Subcompact guns like the SIG Sauer P238 are frequently referred to as pocket pistols, so we had to include a pocket holster on this list.

As far as pocket holsters go, it’s hard to top the DeSantis Nemesis Pocket Holster. It will fit in just about any pocket as long as the pocket is big enough, and the simple holster design makes it ambidextrous, so you can use the holster on either your left or right side. 

The grippy exterior material ensures that the holster stays securely in place, while the smooth interior ensures a smooth draw and keeps the holster from coming out of your pocket along with the gun. 

And don’t worry about people asking if that’s a pistol in your pocket: the holster has a foam core to break up any printing.

 5   Alien Gear ShapeShift Shoulder Holster

If a shoulder holster is more your speed, then we recommend the Alien Gear ShapeShift Shoulder Holster.

It’s available in either black or brown leather, and with the holster on either the right or left hand side, with two mag slots on the other. 

The holster is super adjustable. It has adjustable straps to customize the holster’s fit to your body’s shape and size and adjustable retention and cant on the gun holster, plus an optional thumb release. The mag slots also have adjustable retention. You can also combine the holster shell with Alien Gear ShapeShift Expansion Packs to use the same holster shell in different carry positions.

The straps have neoprene padding for comfort and breathability. The wide straps and belt hooks also distribute weight and prevent this holster from digging into your shoulders like other shoulder holsters. The leather straps have bound edges for additional comfort. At the same time, the holster straps are thin for easy concealability. 

The holster is made in the USA and comes with Alien Gear’s Forever Warranty.

 6   ComfortTac Ultimate Ankle Holster For Concealed Carry

Because of its small size, the SIG P238 is a common choice for a backup gun, so we’d be remiss to not include an ankle holster here. The ComfortTac Ultimate Ankle Holster is basically the perfect choice.

It features an elastic holster with padding for comfort and a breathable, low profile neoprene band. The retention strap is sewn into the holster to avoid leg irritation, while the holster itself is double layered for durability. 

The snap closure retention strap avoids Velcro noises that give away your position in a tactical situation, while holding the gun secure enough for wear during exercise.

The holster is available in two band size options, plus the band is stretchy, so this holster works with a wide variety of different ankle and calf sizes.

It also has an ambidextrous design and can be worn on the inside or outside of the ankle and at different heights on the ankle. It can even be worn inside a boot with sufficient calf and ankle space or worn without socks.

 7   Roma Leathers Essential Leather Concealment Crossbody Bag

Finally, we have a concealed carry purse, the Roma Leathers Essential Leather Concealment Crossbody bag.

We don’t typically recommend off-body carry, but if you must do it for some reason, the crossbody design of this purse makes it easier to keep your gun close to your body, no matter the activity, while also keeping your hands free. 

And it’s not ugly or expensive like most concealed carry purses.

The gun goes into a velcro holster in the zipper closure gun pocket, which has lockable zippers on either side for ambidextrous wear. The holster is repositionable and removable, and the bag comes with two keys. 

The large main pocket, smaller interior pockets, and additional exterior pockets provide plenty of room for regular purse things in addition to your P238. The adjustable, removable shoulder straps are wire reinforced, so they can’t be cut by a would-be thief.

The Roma Leathers Essential Leather Concealment Crossbody Bag is made from real leather and is available in several colors.

Final Thoughts

All of the SIG P238 holsters that we’ve recommended here are great buys. If we had to pick an overall top pick, it would be the Badger Concealment Guardian Inside the Waistband Holster, simply because the low profile and IWB design make it versatile enough to work for the vast majority of Sig P238 holsters. However, the best one for you depends on your particular wants and needs. With the information that we’ve given here, however, you should have no trouble finding the best holster for SIG P238 to meet your needs.